Earlier this week, Fox TV Show Gotham reached its mid season conclusion. The show, which details the events of Detective James Gordon in the crooked police force prior to the arrival of Batman, will return in January but, thus far, prospects are looking good. I was being cautious in my optimism when I previewed the show back in September, given that Marvel’s Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. wasted what I felt was vast potential. Of course, it still got a second season and it’s not really close to getting cancelled so it wasn’t that bad.

In regards to the numbers, Gotham is beating Marvel’s Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. in the ratings by virtue of about two million viewers. That’s actually a bit misleading though. When compared to Marvel’s Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. first season, Agent’s tenth episode actually did better than Gotham, though not by much. It might be worth noting though that Agent’s fell further, having drew over twelve million for the pilot before dropping to about six million for the mid season. Gotham started lower, at eight million but quickly leveled out to somewhere in the region of six million.

What that suggests is that Gotham has managed to hold on to most of it’s initial viewers. Two thirds of the viewers who tuned into the pilot are still hanging around to see the adventures of Benjamin McKenzie as Detective James Gordon. But it’s also useful in predicting the future by suggesting that by this time next year when Gotham is in its second season, it may have shed a further third. But that doesn’t necessarily matter. If Gotham goes to Netflix in the interim between seasons, it could pick up a strong online viewership and following that could keep it afloat despite fletching ratings, or could even help to improve ratings. Netflix was a big reason for Breaking Bad’s surge in popularity.

Benjamin McKenzie stars as Detective James Gordon in Fox's Gotham.

Anger is a common emotion of a man with a city fighting against him.

Ratings are not a reason to watch a show, however. Gotham’s premise is strong and it allows for some good stories. The story of Detective James Gordon coming up the ranks and cleaning up the police force in the years prior to Batman draws from the comic book arc ‘Batman: Year One’, written by Frank Millar, but with one notable change. No Batman. So often in Batman films and programmes and comics, we are told that Gotham is corrupt and needs Batman. Gotham presents that city and we begin to see how much it needs Batman’s intervention as Gordon struggles to enforce justice, constantly taking one step forward and falling two steps back.

Part of the problem I had with Marvel’s Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. was that it never truly detached itself from the wider universe. The team would spend episodes going on cool sounding missions but those missions always had something to do with Extremis or they would talk about Thor and Captain America, basically reminding the audience of the more exciting things going on that this team isn’t a part of. It was like someone wrote a fanfiction where they and their friends were friends with the Marvel superheroes but the superheroes never show up. It gets boring when you’re watching a show for it’s special guest appearances.

As I said in my preview, Gotham avoids that issue by virtue of just being itself. Gotham can actually give us Batman, albeit the innocent boy version but that’s an interesting story in of itself. Viewers know the story of Bruce Wayne training to become Batman, but Gotham explores how seeing his parents murdered drives the boy to become a crime fighter. How did he become the world’s greatest detective? Gotham shows him poring over police files and analysing crime scenes. When did he begin to develop his physical strength and ability? Gotham reveals that Bruce was bullied and asks Alfred to teach him to fight. It’s very compelling to see Bruce Wayne growing into Batman.

David Mazouz and Camren Bicondova star as Bruce Wayne and Selena Kyle in Fox's Gotham.

This might be the most amicable that we’ve ever seen Batman and Catwoman.

The actors themselves are great, with David Mazouz, Sean Pertwee and Robin Lord Taylor as the standouts among the cast. Mazouz plays Bruce with surprising deftness considering his age and Pertwee manages to strike a well maintained balance of mentor, authority figure and servant which draws audiences into scenes without stealing the spotlight. Taylor too is truly creepy as Oswald Cobblepot, already known as The Penguin. Outside of those three I have seen praise for Jada Pinkett Smith and criticism of Benjamin McKenzie. My feelings are to the contrary. Personally, I believe McKenzie brings an earnestness to the role that makes him genuine and sympathetic. Furthermore, the show hasn’t given him much range to display other than gritted determinism and frustration. Pinkett Smith, on the other hand, often comes across as over the top.

That might be a problem with the tone of the show rather than the fault of Pinkett Smith’s acting. There is an issue in that at times the writers want Gotham to be gritty and realistic, like the recent Christopher Nolan trilogy, but then it veers towards Adam West territory by introducing villains such as ‘Balloonman’ who kills his victims by strapping them to weather balloons. It’s true that Batman has his fair share of silly villains and comical stories but they generally vary from writer to writer, not from scene to scene.

So far Gotham has been enjoyable to watch. There’s an obvious shelf life on the story, given that at some point Bruce Wayne has to disappear for training. If he waits too long, characters such as Harvey Dent and Edward Nygma, who are already several years older than the boy, will be old men by the time he takes up the mantle of Caped Crusader. Until then, I’m just going to enjoy the journey and look forward to the change of scenery as Gordon takes up a security position in the newly opened Arkham Asylum.


2 thoughts on “Brooding

  1. I think that your assessment is thorough and on the mark for the most part. I’ve never been at all interested in or familiar with the Batman universe or mythology, so I’m watching in spite of that. That may explain some of my disappointments and criticisms with trotting out random characters to take up valuable time, which I can only assume is being done to appease the true fans. The problem is, it detracts from the show itself.

    I think that Ben McKenzie has a thankless job as the protagonist who isn’t Batman. He’s never going to be who those fans want even though he’s not a substitute. I think he’s done an amazing job, although I think that he’s a terrific, understated actor who needs very little to work with and can make the most subtle nuances really shine. That’s not necessarily working in his favor in an often over-the-top environment with characters and actors hamming it up (like JPS and several others, including RLT, who is better when he tones it down as well) and things racing at breakneck speed. Some slower moments would give him a chance to show tremendous range and different sides of the emotional spectrum, but I wonder how much has been compressed and edited for time, procedural elements, and introducing random characters instead. Developing the main character and story guide should be top of the list with the rest to follow. The writers really haven’t done him any favors at all, but he’s made the best of it, especially in episodes 7, some of 8 and 10. Even 4 had glimpses of what was possible if he was given the opportunity.

    Like you said, I’m hoping that the Arkham stint to come will allow for more range, better stories, characterization and with Gordon interacting with new characters in more powerful scenarios (without Barbara) on a personal level, that there will be a shift to bigger and better things.

    Liked by 1 person

    • I’m glad you liked the post. I completely agree with your assessment of Ben McKenzie’s role within the show. Most of the episodes that have aired so far were filmed before the fall season began. It will be interesting to see if the structure or emphasis of the next 12 episodes changes now that new episodes are being filmed after editors and producers have been able to see the reactions to those first 10.


And now for the rebuttal:

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s